When it comes to golden-era Hong Kong comedies featuring three rascals together, many think of 1+3 Whose Child Is It? (English title: The Faithful Couple, released 1988). This film has a hilariously absurd plot about three close friends who get so drunk they don't know who fathered the barber shop owner's daughter. Directed by Wong Wa-Kei, it brings together beloved stars Stephen Chow, Jacky Cheung, and Max Mok for a perfect blend of comedy. Although its TMDB score is modest (4.9/10), for classic film fans, this movie has an unforgettable charm.
Plot Summary (No Spoilers)
The story follows three rascals: Happy Chan (Jacky Cheung), Ki Ho-Yan (Max Mok), and Puddin Lai (Stephen Chow), who decide to open a new barbershop next to an old one owned by Chuk Tai-Chung (Richard Ng), who is furious. But things take a turn when Chuk's daughter Ying (Sharla Cheung) captivates the three, and they try every trick to woo her. One day, after heavy drinking, no one remembers what happened. Months later, Ying is pregnant, forcing the three to take responsibility and find out who the real father is. The film unfolds with comedic gags and the trio's attempts to please Ying and her father while solving the mystery.
Acting and Characters
The film's highlight is the performance of the three leads, each with their own style. Stephen Chow (Puddin Lai) delivers his signature innocent humor, though not yet at his peak, still bringing smiles. Jacky Cheung (Happy Chan) portrays a playful naivety well, while Max Mok (Ki Ho-Yan) adds spice with his mischievous role. The heroine Sharla Cheung (Ying) is charming and adorable. Richard Ng and Lydia Shum as Ying's parents deliver perfect comedic timing. Overall, the cast drives the film to be fun and engaging.
Direction, Cinematography, and Music
Directed by Wong Wa-Kei, known for many comedies, the film focuses on fast-paced gags and universal humor. While not technically outstanding, it effectively tells a complex story simply. The visuals are typical 80s Hong Kong style, with bright colors and intimate character shots. The soundtrack features pop songs of the era that enhance the comedy, especially during scenes where the trio tries to win Ying over. However, some editing feels choppy, but it doesn't ruin the experience.
Editorial Analysis
Although 1+3 Whose Child Is It? is not groundbreaking or deep, its charm lies in its 'not taking itself seriously' attitude and blending slapstick with improbable situations. The film reflects male competitiveness and rascality in 80s Hong Kong society. The question 'Who is the father?' serves as the main gag but also builds character relationships and audience empathy. However, it may not appeal to younger viewers used to more realistic comedies. It represents pure, mindless comedy – just laugh at the trio's antics, and that's enough.
Verdict
In conclusion, 1+3 Whose Child Is It? is a Hong Kong comedy perfect for those nostalgic for 80s films or fans of the three leads. It's not deep or flawless, but it has funny gags and enjoyable performances. If you like lighthearted comedies that make you smile, give it a watch – you won't be disappointed.
Screenshots
👍 Pros
- +Great chemistry and performances from the three leads
- +Absurd but fun plot, easy to watch
- +Classic comedy gags that still make you laugh today
👎 Cons
- −Pacing sometimes slow or choppy
- −Some jokes may feel dated or repetitive for modern audiences
- −Production and technical aspects are unremarkable
Top Cast
FAQ
Yes, it's one of Stephen Chow's early works, alongside Jacky Cheung and Max Mok.
It's available on DVD or some streaming platforms, mostly with Thai subtitles.
No spoilers, but the ending reveals who the father is and has a happy ending.
Yes, the international title is The Faithful Couple. The Thai title refers to the three men competing to be the father.
